MG-Cars.net

Welcome to our resource for MG Car Information.

Recommendations

Parts

MG parts spares and accessories are available for MG T Series (TA, MG TB, MG TC, MG TD, MG TF), Magnette, MGA, Twin cam, MGB, MGBGT, MGC, MGC GT, MG Midget, Sprite and other MG models from British car spares company LBCarCo.

MG Midget and Sprite Technical - Broken speedo drive - again

Very similar problem to the one raised by Les a couple of weeks ago. My speedometer inner cable has snapped off at the gearbox end, leaving nothing to get a hold of to remove the end bit.
In this case it isn't into an angle drive but direct into the speedo drive gear of a type 9 gearbox. I spent nearly 2 hours lying under the car this morning trying with various pics and devices trying to lever the broken remnants out, but without success. I need information and advice!

Firstly, it would be good to be able to remove the gear to work on at the bench. I do recollect when setting up this t9 gearbox, I had a selection of different (coloured) nylon gears with varying numbers of teeth, and trying several to get a reasonably accurate speedometer reading. And I must have been doing this with the gearbox installed in the car. What I don't recall is how I could swap the gears out and whether when the gear is removed, does it drain the gearbox oil?

Opposite the drive end is a largish cover plate which looks like it is a press fit in the tailshaft casting. Do I need to remove this to get the driven gear out that way instead? And again, would removing this result in a torrent of oil?
GuyW

"Opposite the drive end is a largish cover plate which looks like it is a press fit in the tailshaft casting. Do I need to remove this to get the driven gear out that way instead? And again, would removing this result in a torrent of oil? "

Yes you have to remove that cover.

If the tail is raised up the oil 'should' stay in the box. May be a bit, but not a torrent.

But I've only done it out of the car. I wasn't aware it was accessible in the car. I haven't looked though, but figured it was obscured by the tunnel.

Perhaps you've cut your tunnel floor back farther than I did. Thus your cover is visible/accessible. But still not easy in car I wouldn't have thought.

Been a while since I tried though. I'll have to refresh my memory, by getting under and or looking at my laptop pictures. Lol.

anamnesis

Thanks Anamn. The odd thing, with memory that is, that I am convinced that when setting this up I know I tried 3 different coloured speedo cable drive gears. Green, brown and black which had different numbers of teeth. I settled on green with AFAIR 22 teeth to get a correct speed on the dial. As this needed road testing between each swap I am pretty sure I wasnt removing the engine and gearbox each time!

I can see the cover plate and access the lower half of the edge from under the car so I will have a go at it, with caution! It will need a selection of sharp edge tools.
GuyW

Does the cap actually hold the speedo gear in place or is there a circlip inside, can’t remember.
This can be a right pain to remove and needs hitting in with a mallet when reinstalling.
Don’t think you will loose much oil, just a dribble. Can’t understand why there is no drain plug! I fitted one to my box when stripped it down.
Good luck.
Les Robinson

Just looked at my gearbox manual and it would appear that it’s the cap that holds the gear in place.


Les Robinson

Just a thought. Could you connect a bit of garden house, or flexible pipe that will fit nicely on the gearbox box end and then connect the other end to a vacuum cleaner and try to suck it out?

James Paul

Guy
You mentioned that you have a green speedo gear with 22 teeth.
I have a white gear with 24 teeth - no idea how I chose that one, it was 16 years ago now! But seems to give fairly accurate reading. Diff is 3.9
Les Robinson

Thanks Les. Yes I seem to recall that the cap just has a flat base which the end of the gear runs against. Whether I can get the cap off with the gearbox in situ will depend on how tightly the fit is. But the incentive to persist is considerable as the alternative is a full engine removal job!
My gearbox does have a drain plug too!

James, I do like your thinking but I really think the broken end is too tightly wedged in place for a hoover or even a dyson amount of suction to displace.

Wet again today so another reason to defer this challenge!
GuyW

Memory Les. A wonderful thing when it works! Pretty sure the one in here is green and I think 22 teeth.

Its an interesting esoteric point as to why or indeed how, the brain retains some sort of record of seemingly random and inconsequential details from ones life often over decades. What is the benefit of that ability from an evolutionary or survival point of view?
GuyW

Maybe no benefit at all Guy.

We may like to think nature -- (or creation if you are of that persuasion) is somehow perfect.

But actually there are mistakes and redundancies. Some of which cause problems. Like our appendix. No longer needed, and might kill you if infected and ruptures. Or a mistake like a hole in your heart. And false memories.

Evolution progresses by experiments in nature. Some lead to dead ends, or later problems.

Not putting a drain plug in a t9 looks like a mistake by Ford. But the design was for it never to need an oil change. The cars weren't supposed to last that long. 80/90 thousand miles, car scrapped.

Ford didn't expect someone to plonk T9's in kit cars and Spridgets years later.

If Ford is the equivalent to Nature and creation, difficulty changing a speedo drive or removing a broken cable might be considered 'imperfections'. Lol.

Or, it may be a benefit, as it taxes old minds and bodies to come up with solutions; such as a dyson..🤣.

Or laying on ones back under a car aged over 70, instead of laying in bed.

Which is better for your health? 🤣. --- And your mind - memory.

Laying under a car at age 70 plus certainly sticks in the mind, though I'm doubtful of the benefit of remembering it. 🤣.

anamnesis

I can barely remember lying on my back at age 70!
Seems like a long time ago. Or maybe "Yesterday" as my 4 year old grandson uses for any event in the past. "we went on holiday yesterday" he will say - a bit confusing to the adult brain which knows he was at playschool. But maybe a more useful concept of time. Yesterday and Tomorrow. That will do for me.
GuyW

Sunday morning browsing for information on this speedo drive gear problem.
From an ebay image I see there is a central hole in the opposite end of the drive gear spindle. If this goes right through the full length that suggests that one could poke something through to push the broken bit of the cable out. So if I can remove the gear to the bench that should make it easy.
But, does that hole go right through? Anyone got a spare gear accessible that they could look at for me?
GuyW

I mentioned earlier that I had a 24 tooth gear (white), that is correct. However my diff is 4.22 and not 3.9!
Les Robinson

Les, I did wonder as my speedo was reasonably accurate with the 22 pinion gear. Certainly within the 'waver range' of the dial needle.

My car has the 3.9 diff
GuyW

It was Bernie that questioned me. I was going to put error down to old age but Bernie is older than me!
Les Robinson

Unfortunately, at least on my spare, it's a blind hole.

About an inch deep from either end. There can't be much plastic between the two holes, but if it were bottomless, would that allow the cable to penetrate too deeply? And it's probably blind to stop oil leaking out of the tail that way; **note the oil scroll**. Though that makes me wonder why there's a rear hole anyway. Oooer missus. 🤣

Anyway, you aren't alone in your endevour. See this discussion about removing the driven gear with the box in situ. He succeeded in removing the cap and the driven gear.

https://www.caterhamlotus7.club/forums/topic/243179-type-9-speedo-drive-gear/

So take courage, as they used to say.😉

https://youtu.be/uQzIq05gIcc?si=j6AzLL4GKavVa_h5






anamnesis

Thanks aAnamn. That link is both concerning and also a success, of sorts!

<<after a couple of hours under the car I got the cap off and the 24 tooth drive gear out. Not an enjoyable job.Then I found there was no output shaft speedo drive gear fitted! >>

So in the end in his case, getting the gear out wasn't helpful as the corresponding snail cog on the output shaft was missing!

In my case the idea was that it would be easier working on my green output gear if it were on the bench. But if removing it is such a hassle I may revert to lying on my back under the car and continuing the original attempt to prise the broken off end of the drive cable out with it in situ.

GuyW

Guy,

Just a thought if you have any very small taps - assuming the cable is of the curtain wire type- can you screw / force the end of a sharp fine tap in to get a bit of purchase ?
Probably need to be 7/8/ 10 BA but don’t snap it off !
Maybe a scriber point first to open it up a bit.

As I said just a thought !
richard b

A nice idea Richard. I have already tried to get a self tapping screw to bite but couldn't get it started. The wire strands seem quite hard which rather surprised me when they do need to flex a bit on use.
GuyW

The hardness of the steel has no effect on its stiffness.
David Billington

How about a really strong magnet? I know it will stick to the spindle too but when you pull it off the cable might come with it.

Trev
T Mason

Very small contact area with the end of the cable and I think the part is wedged in there pretty tightly.
But I will try anything Trev!
GuyW

Still struggling with my speedo drive cable connection at the gearbox end.
The problem is that the cable end broke off down inside the end of the gear.
I have tried and failed to remove the cap from the gearbox tailshaft which would have allowed me to remove the pinion gear to work on at the bench so access isn't great under the car.

I have tried for several hours to get hold of the broken off piece but it is tightly wedged in place, with the end about 4mm down inside the nylon square socket. The nylon socket end is now pretty chewed up, but I still think if I can get the remnants out I could could re-form the socket end with epoxy resin (araldite or some such) as it is contained within the metal sleeve end.

Bits of the broken cable have been coming out as shreds of wire, but not enough to loosen it. But what I cannot tell is how deep the socket is. Might I have bottomed out and just be digging at the blind end of it? Perhaps, Anamn, you could check the depth on that blue one of yours with a bit of wire?


There are solutions.
One is to remove engine and gearbox. Get the tailshaft plate off and work on the gear on the bench. Easier than under the car but might not progress any further in which case its buy a new gear pinion.
The other is a phone speedo App as they are pretty accurate. But in my mind for a Spridget that's a work around rather than a fix.
GuyW

Speedo drive. Somewhat chewed after 3 hours!


GuyW

Spent pretty well all day on this. It worked for about 100 yds up the road. Too p1$$ed off to investigate why but its looking like it wont get sorted without an engine extraction. Grrr. Too many birthdays for this game!
GuyW

Guy,

Been there and have vented as such on here, but went for a blat today, worth it all.

It's September, just get the satnav speedo for a month or two and fix the gearbox drive over winter

Mal
Malc Gilliver

Guy, not what they are meant for but would a pair of circlip pliers grab hold of it or a large pair of pointed tweezers?

Trev
T Mason

Unfortunately not,Trev. I tried all sorts. The remnants of the broken bit of cable are well embedded into the socket and about 4mm down with no space around the outside of the broken off piece to get any sort of tweezers or similar on to it.
GuyW

Guy
As you have pull a few bits out it might be worth another go with the finest self taper you have or a tap.

I do know just how frustrating this type of issue can be - you have my sympathy !
richard b

About an inch deep Guy.

But really, you need a 'new' gear.

As annoying as it is, I think you've done all you can to avoid pulling the engine and box.

Heroic effort, but sometimes it doesn't work out.

I know exactly how you feel re too many birthdays too.

You just have to make the decision, and do it. One last time hopefully.

So gather a replacement speedo gear, and be prepared to replace anything else one last time while the engine is out, and get stuck in.

Mind over body. 🙂.





anamnesis

Quite right Anamn. People (and this now includes moi) make a big thing about engine removal preparing for weeks in advance. And yet, when this car and I were both a lot younger, I remember setting a stop watch and removing the engune and gearbox in 1hr, 10 minutes. That was from a running car, driven in to the garage to power unit sitting on the floor. And reverse was just over 1hr 20, back to car ready to turn the key.

The magic was new nuts, the correct spanners read, including a couple of 'specials' and like you, Anamn, some slight modifications to ease the process.

0nce, when installing an overdrive in my 1500 I 'R &R' the whole unit 4 times in a day.

We make too much ado about nothing of our simple cars!
GuyW

The ravages of time Guy.

I reckon we can be forgiven for having a moan and a groan, when now contemplating tasks we once scorned others, for thinking 'hard' to do. 😅.

With less time to waste, with gritted teeth we've got to bring in that final harvest. 😉.


" Time is a jet plane, it moves too fast
Oh, but what a shame
That all we've had can't last -"
Dylan.


" -- star-crossed in pleasure, the stream flows on by --as we're sated in leisure, we watch it fly --

Time can tear down a building or destroy a frogeye's face
Hours are like diamonds, don't let them waste

Time waits for no one, no favors has he
Time waits for no one, and he won't wait for me

Drink in your summer, gather your corn
The dreams of the nighttime will vanish by dawn
Jagger/Richards/(Taylor).

"DO IT NOW!!!"
Corrine. (One of my Ex's). 😂

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YsH2In5r2sM



anamnesis

Looking at Anamn's photo of the Speedo drive gear made me consider a possible solution. If the hole down the middle extends about 1" from each end, there cannot be a great deal of material in the middle. I doubt if the whole component is much over 2" anyway. So in theory I could drill through the middle bit and poke a stiff wire through to dislodge the broken off bit of drive cable. Then push a plug down to replicate the internal barrier.

Sounds easy enough but still requires removal of the tail shaft blanking disc which in turn means gearbox removal. Having got that far I might as well just fit a new pinion gear (around. £45)

I have one more thought before this. It really is what I believe is an Americanism, which is a Hail Mary, last ditch idea.
If the socket hole in the drive gear, cable end, is 1" deep as Anamn reports, and IF the broken off bit isn't too long (big assumption) then I may be able to drive the remnant far enough in to vacate sufficient of the square section hole to engage a new Speedo cable end.
It's a risky, burnt bridges solution but as the only alternative means replacing the gear anyway I may as well just try that.
GuyW

Anyone know roughly what length of the squared section drive cable normally engages? My broken cable still has around 22mm of squared bit left. Almost as much as at the top end (25mm) rather suggesting gat only a very short bit has broken off in there? Unless the cable bottom end flattened bit was a good deal longer than at the top. ???
GuyW

Well! That was easy!!
Squared off the sides of a 60mm round wire nail and the image shows how far the broken bit has pushed up inside the gear, That surely should be enough to engage the cable end.
GuyW

Guy
In terms of length of engagement into the gear, from doing mine then as an approximation it’s the length that the gear protrudes from the casing plus approx 6mm. That’s what I seem to remember anyway!
Les Robinson

No picture Guy.

But from your description, a very clever solution. 👍👏👏.

Saved a lot of work, and is as good as a replacement.

anamnesis

BBS won't accept my photo ??

Not quite plain sailing as the socket is slightly too small to accept the cable properly. I can get about 7mm of engagement though as the socket ends is a bit chewed, there is probably only 4mm actual fixed in there.
GuyW

During this thread I've been wondering if the gearbox speedo output shaft is substantial enough to allow tapping it to remove the closing bung. I've fitted a few to various Ford gearboxes and they've never been tight, a bit of Hylomar to seal and tap them into place. Any thoughts?
David Billington

David, Bearing in mind I am working from underneath, so only get access to about 1/3rd of the circumference, I haven't been able to shift it. The closing cap is a bit like a paint tin lid with a lip around the edge one can get a thin tool (old wood chisel followed by broad flat blade screwdriver) and then lever upwards. So far all I have achieved is to bend the flange upwards. Its pretty tight!

The gearbox has been in the car for 20 or so years since I last removed that cover when experimenting with speedo gear teeth numbers. The drive gear is mostly nylon or some sort of non brittle plastic. Only the output end where it runs an oil seal is it sleeved in steel. I dont think it would double up as a punch to push the cap off. I'm not sure but I think the steel cap actually doubles as a surface to take axial loading of the gear.
GuyW

Here's that missing photo. Nail, squared off in grinder and used to push the broken remnant of cable 20mm back up inside the gear wheel shaft.

After a fair struggle this turned out to be successful and so easy it could well be a good solution to anyone else in the future faced with the problem of extracting a remnant like that.

I suspect the broken bit was very short and that in a way points to the next problem and probable original cause.

This is a 'special' cable. Assembled from an MGB cable (for extra length) with a Ford trumpet shaped ferrule at the bottom end. Not new, its been in use for many years. But on reassembly the inner is now too short. I have a spare inner, but who knew there are two different thicknesses? Anyway, I have a mis match of parts, inner and outer cables and ferrule ends so tomorrow morning's job will be a bit of cutting, crimping and fettling.



GuyW

Only 4mm. Not a lot, but perhaps it's all it needs to run for many thousands of miles.

You don't have anything to lose by trying it; and if it works you've gained avoiding engine/box extraction.

Pretty difficult to shift that cap Guy. I've just read it's 14mm penetration and I remember it's a tight fit with a mallet. Even with those raised areas in the flange, without better access, it's box out I would think.

And yep, as you say,

" --- the steel cap actually doubles as a surface to take axial loading of the gear."


A couple of pictures.






anamnesis

All back together now but although the cable whizzes and the speedometer needle moves as it should - re-insert the speedo into the dash and its gone to sleep again!
Clearly this has been one of those legendary 5 minute jobs. Broken speedo cable? Fit a new one. Job done.
GuyW

Is it a case of when you bend the cable the inner shortens and pulls out of the gearbox drive. Maybe you'll have to shorten the outer and move the Ford connection end along. I did the same mod to mine when I fitted a Ford box back around 1988, and had to grind a small amount off the inner square end to fit in the Ford drive.
David Billington

Maybe something like that. I have now got a good secure connection at the gearbox end. Then I measured up and cut the outer and refitted the end ferrule to give 9/16" of inner protruding at the speedometer end. That looks to me to be plenty!

I am wondering if there should be some sort of spring clip or liner in the female connector of the speedo. Peering down the hole it just looks round! I may have lost it. In more ways than one!
GuyW

I do have a spare speedometer, but the number on the faceplate is very different. From memory that relates to the gearing? Turns per mile or something of that sort. Is that right?
GuyW

Think so


The speedo should have numbers on it 1472 (4.22) or 1376 (3.9) ISTR !

Just had a look at my spare 1376 one
Just a plastic hole did not engage to drive speedo properly until it was in quite a way, using the square end of a tap as far as it would go (think it bottomed was about 12/13mm.

Not sure what size the inner cable square and is though.
richard b

This thread was discussed between 11/09/2026 and 27/09/2026

MG Midget and Sprite Technical index

This thread is from the archive. The Live MG Midget and Sprite Technical BBS is active now.